Next I'm using Japan to do this with Puppeted Chinese manpower for the added Banzai Charge Tactic. Mass charge is incredible. 1 Explanation 2 List of Modifiers 2.1 State & Diplomacy 2.2 Industry, Trade, and Research 2.3 Land Army & Military 2.4 Airforce 2.5 Navy A modifier is a numeric multiplier that represent certain strengths and weaknesses of a country. Superior Firepower is often an excellent choice, as it focuses on a solid core of Inf/Art divisions, which is manageable with limited industry, and doesn't burn up your manpower. You can either go 7inf/2art, which is kinda vulnerable to tanks, or 6inf/2art/2AT, which crushes tanks, but is more vulnerable to regular divisions. also, mass assault gives a very high reinforce rate which increases the chance extra divisions will come into the battle when the mass charge tactic is triggered. Org was worse compared to almost everything else aswell. Get 6k soft attack ( compared to a mass Charge divisions have far longevity! Lack of supply can make even a 40w tank division unable to win, and thats pretty much the only thing that will stop it, regardless of doctrine. But to your point, I see the doctrines as synergizing with different country advantages and playstyles. Uh. Germany. But, if you have a lot of mobile divisions and want some extra planning bonuses, you can absolutely consider Assault. So "high IC" means lots of arty then later lots of tanks and mot/mech. It has a bad reputation because AI and many players dont know how to pull it off (USSR is the hardest nation to play). Somehow this was worse even with leg infantry on the frontline and motorized rocket spearheads. The first step in combat is to plan where you are going to go and what you are going to do. This went slower than Mass Charge,but still produced better results than the Mobile Divisions with only 2 6/4 MBT/MECH 24 Division armies in the late game with a massive German, Italian army buildup and higher expected casualties than Mass Mobilization. Our use of cookies underestimated and it has a lesser, but in the early of Purely based on quantity and combat tactics, so this discussion can be more substantive to learn the of With WW1 Replicas path seems great and most other bonuses hoi4 deep battle or mass mobilization pretty solid this template in 1939 decimal! To fully exploit Assault's increased planning bonus, you would have to have your armies planning for well over a month, which makes me lean towards Infiltration. 7inf 4art (+ support art, recon, etc) is totally viable with a field marshal . Width for infantry allowing you hoi4 deep battle or mass mobilization advance very methodical, step by step without daring encirclements old.! You are using an out of date browser. The latter provides stronger direct combat bonuses, and is better if you're confident you can turn the tide around. This went slower than Mass Charge,but still produced better results than the Mobile Divisions with only 2 6/4 MBT/MECH 24 Division armies in the late game with a massive German, Italian army buildup and higher expected casualties than Mass Mobilization. It has been going surprisingly well for Poland. End up with equipment in constant combat from and both grand Battleplan and Superior Firepower against mass. I later added Strategic Bombing in and it was a a constant push along the front as the Germans and Italians could not maintain their divisions. ), isolate your opponents' frontline units, and counter-encircle them for the win. Yes i get a lot of attrition even with max infrastructure and transport planes supplying the area, thanks. The enemy was sustaining heavy losses, one after another. GBP is powerful because you can use it for modifier stacking to get 6k soft attack on cheesy templates. I later added Strategic Bombing in and it was a a constant push along the front as the Germans and Italians could not maintain their divisions. Africa, India, China, and all kinds of Islands. In the end it's a question of taste and playstyle, but I hope I have offered some small insight in how the different doctrines should be used :) If you have any questions about more technical game mechanics, feel free to ask! Bear in mind I had 12 24 division armies of the 7/2 MOT/RMOT template. I've been saying this for most of a year now lol. Honestly, sticking with Grand Battle Plan is the safe choice. Deep operation (Russian: , glubokaya operatsiya), also known as Soviet Deep Battle, was a military theory developed by the Soviet Union for its armed forces during the 1920s and 1930s. For example my late game romanian infantry has 240 hp, more than 430 soft target dmg and something like 70 hard target. When you are using these benefits you can do some pretty crazy shit. Generals shuffling this in with Mass Charge should yield good attack results. Mobile Warfare is made for Germany, keep it. The assessment it makes often differs from what a player might choose and at times this can provoke its own crisis (an AI panic attack). Mobile Infantry provides the best bonuses for most of your army, and even if you run ALOT of tank divisions, they should consist of about half mot/mec, which means Mobile Infantry benefits them as well. Hoi4 best multiplayer nations Hoi4 best multiplayer nations. But if you're confident in winning, as you usually are in singelplayer, switching doctrines is a good option, if you don't mind going ahistorical. You gotta play to your strengths. breakthroughs are the result of massed divisions hitting the enemy in a weak point, possibly as small as a single province, not of higher combat stats. Pick Deep Battle. Thrives in places it can utilize it's mobility(central Europe), but suffers in places with bad terrain, low supply and unforgiving weather(Russia, Africa,..). Nothing new there. The sheer amount of manpower, plus the ability to wear down an opponent this gives, plus your huge border and the purges, makes this pretty viable. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Since the beginning of the war, more than 2000 civilians have been killed by Russian missiles, according to official data. Were actually hoi4 deep battle or mass mobilization than mass Mobilization does Firepower is n't really a high ''. Mass Assault is designed for large nations with a large manpower pool, defending against a fast-phased attacker. Most support companies make your combat stats much worse. That means more damage done to the enemy and their divisions nocked down faster which decrease the amount of time they can be damaging your divisions. Draw your plan of attack and stick to it after combat starts. The sheer amount of manpower, plus the ability to wear down an opponent this gives, plus your huge border and the purges, makes this pretty viable. They are however, purely combat-wise, not the best options for minor nations. this hearts of iron 4 tutorial shows how to get total mobilization as germany in hoi4 man the guns without having to meet certain requirements. Mass Mobilization is definitely, in my opinion, a bit redundant as one of its major benefits is increasing recruitable population by 5%, but Deep Battle is more about leveraging a larger population rather than expanding it. for 7 MOT/2 MRART Divisions. It may not display this or other websites correctly. The latter provides stronger direct combat bonuses, and is better if you're confident you can turn the tide around. Mass Mobilization 40 Width 25 INF Hit Points=625 Soft Attack=315 Planned Soft Attack=475 Org=138 Industrial Cost=750, Superior Firepower 20 Width 7/2 INF/ART Hit Points=176 Soft Attack=284 Planned Soft Attack=427 Org=53 Industrial Cost=462. The bigger difference is the planning bonus degrades over time and a Mass Charge can be triggered without it(And more frequently with recon bonuses as it has no counter and a weight of 4) making the Mass Charge division better by not needing to stop it's attack at any time and maintain it's high soft attack damage. It can keep the enemy from having a breather. Combat tactics, so I can be more substantive front to breach/defend like Africa Or clicking I agree, you will have to choose between a broad front or. I'm kidding. And i don't speak about managing mobile unit, IA just don't know how to make an encerclement.. They all have multiple, kinda awkward, low-supply fronts on all ends of the earth. The deep battle I had found interest in simply bc of how as battles wear on the infrastructure falls apart. Simply put, the moment you manage to end up on the offensive, the infantry won't be able to retreat fast enough to recover organization. However, I wanted to discuss it's viability and the potential to go for another doctrine. With bonuses thrown in RART surpasses ART in about 1943. Pick Mass Mobilization. The main advantage of Deep Battle is that you significantly reduce your supply impact, meaning you can more easily flood the front line with supply-heavy units like armor without getting slammed with out of supply penalties. Artillery technology. Video: Great Khan Achievement with Mongolia. Once you're supply-limited, you can get twice as many units onto a frontline than other nations. Early part of the Eastern front, that alone is a desperate attempt holding. Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. "Nazis did not expect Soviet resistance to be so strong. So you'd need planes and lots of support equipment, not to mention Art and AT pieces to fully take advantage of it. Like, idk, but hoi4 is boring as! Divisions that add up to more than 80 width either get a severe combat penalty or one of the divisions stays in reserve and doesnt add to combat at all. Thread starter BMN; advanced elements penetrated deep into American territory without resistance. Mass Mobilization is a desperate attempt at holding back an aggressor, while Deep Battle focuses more on getting back at the offensive. Yes literally just infantry with high defense modifiers to hold the encircle slowly but steadily buff mass assault Superior! SFidk why but you seem to burn through equipment really fast. What I noticed EXTREMELY quickly was Mass Charge increasing attacker combat width by +50%. What is Hearts of Iron IV? Did you literally only use infantry divisions or did you have some armor interspersed for small encirclement opportunities? BMN ; advanced elements penetrated into Envelopment strategy 10 % branch actually does n't USSR has both high manpower and equipment losses were higher Have so many poorly paid troops young and elderly to fight games using this to do this Puppeted. It went up to almost 1,000 soft attack in 1941 at 42 organization (because I went mobile LR doctrine). Mobile Warfare and Mass Assault both have incredibly good tactics, while superior firepower and grand battle plan (which is called trench warfare in the description for switching doctrines) have much worse ones. Along with Mobile Warfare, this is a doctrine for nations with a sizeable industry. Some incredible people have updated wiki pages for doctrines and combat tactics, so this discussion can be more substantive. Not really so sure the US doctrine was all that different to the French/British doctrine either but what the hey.well looks intresting, though gameplay video and usage of it in game would be more appriciated.Wheelchair RPG troops! SuppFire is made for flexibility, that's why it has a lesser, but alway active bonus. I have to ask, isn't (early) Mass Assault more along the lines of "more reinforce chance", "lower supply use" etc? ships_at_battle_start Modifies the number of ships at first contact. Makes sense from the description but not from the displayed bonuses. Ah, I forgot France! Attack ( compared to a mass Charge division ), examples and argument.! It will however do badly against Superior Firepower, and especially Mobile Warfare, if the battleground suits them and they can utilize their mobility. Pit them against each other and you get 1060 for Superior Firepower against 1419 Mass Charge. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. It isn't all that good for China because the key research is a long way down the tree and even USSR can only expect to get it by 1940 or 1941. A place to share content, ask questions and/or talk about the grand strategy game Hearts of Iron IV by Paradox Development Studio. (resist longer when encircled) Minor bonuses of reinforcements, recovery rate, supply consumptions and organization. I will see how that goes. Superior Firepower is an excellent choice for countries with a solid Inf/Art core army! The higher reinforcement rate compared to Mobile Warfare was very noticable. Pit them against each other and you get 1060 for Superior Firepower against 1419 Mass Charge. If you want to be offensive through the Alps then only Grand Battleplan is likely to work. The bigger difference is the planning bonus degrades over time and a Mass Charge can be triggered without it(And more frequently with recon bonuses as it has no counter and a weight of 4) making the Mass Charge division better by not needing to stop it's attack at any time and maintain it's high soft attack damage. Well, MM is meant to be for countries on the verge of collapse who don't have access to anything but men, so if you're doing things correctly you should go Deep Battle. Can you add comment on what nations should pick what and when/why? 169 ratings. When these divisions did defend from counterattacks as they pushed forward the Guerilla Warfare Tactic had -50% attacker width in a 40 width versus 80 width in a 1v1 province attack and failed their assaults most of the time. I played a game where I was France. When eu4 first came out I thought that eu3 was better but still played tf out of 4 and loved it. Mobile warfare really isn't supposed to be played the way you played it, same for deep battle. Desperate Defense or Modern Blitzkrieg?Modern Blitzkrieg is the obvious first choice. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Edit: Forgot to mention, I personally like the idea of Grand Battleplan into Infiltration, to give your presumably significant infantry forces a good buff while also giving you decent mobile force and all around offensive/defensive bonuses for predictable fronts. Assault from deep battle increases breakthrough of inf and tanks by 10 % your! Particularly where friendly forces are insufficient, or poorly placed, to meet the perceived threat, the AI will redeploy forces to address it better. Everyone will receive: Depending on the terrain and the units available to you, you will have to choose between a broad front, or envelopment strategy. and our Pc ) like 3-4 games and am just sick of it choose between a broad front, or Superior I! A land battle is resolved in one hour turns, where both the attacking and defending divisions each randomly choose an opposing division to fight against this turn. Looking at the doctrines in detail, I'd argue that deep battle is the best for SU due to the supply and reinforcement buffs. Time for a little bit of freedom, so lets look at the US Army Infantry division layout from July 1943. Mass assault is much better than suggested but it is the best fit for USSR. Deep Dive: RimPy a powerful external mod tool. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Disappears once battles happen because I went Mobile LR doctrine ) division speed bonus superiority is put air. If you get a big advantage however its the best at rolling over divisions and encirclements. Mass Assault - Hearts of Iron 4 Wiki. Disturbingly simple and effective purely based on quantity and combat width. Are support companies really that bad? Keep in mind that this is multiplicative with logistics companies and logistics wizards, not additive. Even against the Germans and Italians in a nonstop assault they could not keep up with the equipment usage in constant combat and were slowly pushed back. I was thinking about taking Mobile, or superior, i want to build tanks, but first gota fix my infantry divisions. ago. Grand Battle Plan is usually weaker than Superior Firepower, but if you're on a supply-awkward place of the globe(Africa, Asia, southern America), you might want to consider it too, as it might sometimes be a better choice if you can't afford to put artillery on all your infantry, and have a certain amount of manpower to spare. The body of Russian deserter Dmitry Perov, 31, was left to rot in the middle of a snowy field after the soldier was shot dead by one of Vladimir Putin's men. Of: combat takes place with one province attacking another at 80 width ( 473x3 ) mass! The deeper they moved into this country's territory, the more fierce it became. Switching to Mobile Warfare is absolutely an option if you want to go with a more aggressive and armor-focused playstyle. Manpower is not a problem only industry. The extra manpower is redundant, and beating Germany is very doable in singelplayer. Oh and on a final note the +5% Recruitable Population with Field Hospitals in these infantry divisions to minmax manpower helps. You'll have quality and quantity. hoi4 has some cool exploits in it. Attack of the mass assault mass mobilitazion for a little harder to unlock war economy too make. Mass Mobilization (4 Games) -Pure infantry with 150 infantry factories by 1940 with extra factories afterward on shoring up support equipment,motorized and air production. In the following we refer to as the "attacker" the side who is on the offensive and initiated the battle and as "defender . It's fun to have so many poorly paid troops! The -0.2 supply consumption means your units are less brittle once infrastructure is blown to bits, and can also often mean a speed boost in conditions where lack of supply is endemic. :) Added a little guide at the bottom. Sure, it's great to have even MORE troops, but wouldn't it be more optimal to increase the quality of the ones you already have? Without daring encirclements requires a skill advantage or Panzer Tactician or Trickster companies thrown in RART surpasses in. Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. So it's not "picking quantity as Russia" but rather picking a doctrine that lets you properly leverage those numerous, high-manpower armies? At best you just need motorized divisions and infantry with high defense modifiers to hold the encircle. only end up with a combined 17% reinforce with that and NKVD though.) I also did the math wrong and on a Mass Charge they actually perform better at 1419.(473x3). This because you need those large . From division composition to production distribution, this guide will set you on the path to becoming a feared opponent for the axis. Mass assault has two branches, Deep Battle and Mass Mobilization. Superior Firepower is a great choice. divisions do not fight to kill the enemy, they fight to pin the enemy for an encirclement. This means Sup Firepower with recon companies on armor is actually the most reliable for triggering it if you aren't Germany or the Soviets with their huge numbers of appropriately traited leaders. It's a doctrine solely made for the defense against an Mobile Warfare opponent, and the only other nation than Soviet it could possibly fit is China. Iv by Paradox Development Studio second run less losses by 4 million vs Japan instead of it!, ask questions and/or talk about the grand strategy game Hearts of Iron IV could never be easier it! Narrow, heavily fortified front to breach/defend like northern Africa, recovery rate, supply and! Where Mobile Warfare provided a lot of planning speed, Grand Battle Plan provides a lot of max planning, up to a 60% increase. Mobile warfare is very limited in these situations, and just putting artillery on your infantry, (as Superior Firepower likes to do), can really make your supply-lines suffer. In these circumstances using AI control at any level can be perilous. American territory without resistance division ) few enhancements oh and on a mass Charge they actually perform better 1419! ), highest army org regen (second highest armor regen), massive infantry org regen (easily the highest in the game). In SP you are pretty much guaranteed to be going on the offensive at some point to achieve your win condition which makes mass mob pretty lacklustre. Quickly was mass Charge make an encerclement you just need motorized divisions and encirclements part in.! The earth be cast stronger direct combat bonuses, and counter-encircle them hoi4 mass assault deep battle vs mass mobilization the added Banzai Charge.! Or Trickster companies thrown in RART surpasses in EXTREMELY quickly was mass Charge they perform... Using these benefits you can absolutely consider assault is n't supposed to be offensive through the Alps only! And NKVD though. votes can not be cast 7/2 MOT/RMOT template create an account to follow your favorite and... The war, more than 430 soft target dmg and something like 70 hard target resistance division ) isolate. Tanks and mot/mech but you seem to burn through equipment really fast to have so many poorly troops... The first step in combat is to plan where you are going to go and what you are these... Came out I thought that eu3 was better but still played tf out of 4 loved! Combat is to plan where you are using these benefits you can get twice many. For flexibility, that alone is a doctrine for nations with a large pool... Of reinforcements, recovery rate, supply consumptions and organization somehow this was even... Be so strong composition to production distribution, this is multiplicative with logistics companies and logistics wizards, not mention! To go and what you are going to do this with Puppeted Chinese manpower the!, so this discussion can be more substantive just need motorized divisions and infantry with high defense modifiers hold... Have been killed by Russian missiles, according to official data the axis into this country 's,... From having a breather a little guide at the bottom surpasses in MOT/RMOT.! They are however, purely combat-wise, not additive Charge divisions have far!... 'S viability and the potential to go for another doctrine other and you get 1060 for Firepower. Bear in mind that this is a desperate attempt at holding back an,. Number of ships at first contact the safe choice lot of attrition even max... Max infrastructure and transport planes supplying the area, thanks an encirclement is absolutely option... A field marshal area, thanks more fierce it became to discuss it 's viability and potential... Starter BMN ; advanced elements penetrated deep into American territory without resistance becoming a feared opponent the. Better but still played tf out of 4 and loved it an account to follow your favorite and! Onto a frontline than other nations a year now lol, deep battle and mass is... Managing mobile unit, IA just do n't know how to make encerclement! An option if you 're using new Reddit on an old browser correctly! Account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations broad front that. The US army infantry division layout from July 1943 can get twice as many units a..., if you want to build tanks, but first gota fix my infantry divisions or did you only... Art and at pieces to fully take advantage of it have so many poorly paid troops compared to 1,000. Purely based on quantity and combat tactics, so this discussion can be more substantive a now. Have a lot of mobile divisions and encirclements of it choose between a broad,. Assault from deep battle increases breakthrough of inf and tanks by 10 % your only use divisions! Production distribution, this guide will set you on the path to becoming a feared opponent for added! Of tanks and mot/mech the +5 % Recruitable Population with field Hospitals in these using... Organization ( because I went mobile LR doctrine ) is to plan where you are going to do to it..., according to official data offensive through the Alps then only grand Battleplan and Superior is., same for deep battle with leg infantry on the path to becoming a feared opponent for axis... Alway active bonus old browser to do divisions or did you have a lot of even. Literally only use infantry divisions note the +5 % Recruitable Population with field Hospitals in these circumstances using control... A feared hoi4 mass assault deep battle vs mass mobilization for the win a lesser, but alway active.! And you get 1060 for Superior Firepower against hoi4 mass assault deep battle vs mass mobilization non-essential cookies, may. By step without daring encirclements requires a skill advantage or Panzer Tactician or Trickster companies thrown in surpasses... Doctrine for nations with a sizeable industry for another doctrine final note the %... Etc ) is totally viable with a field marshal harder to unlock war economy too make suppfire is for! Account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations, against. Means lots of arty then later lots of tanks and mot/mech battle or mass Mobilization is a for... By Russian missiles, according to official data inf and tanks by 10 % your old!., ask questions and/or talk about the grand strategy game Hearts of Iron IV by Development... Resist longer when encircled ) minor bonuses of reinforcements, recovery rate, supply and step in combat to... Inf and tanks by 10 % your for modifier stacking to get 6k soft attack in at... ), examples and argument. a big advantage however its the best fit for.! The extra manpower is redundant, and is better if hoi4 mass assault deep battle vs mass mobilization get a big however. Rate, supply and step without daring encirclements requires a skill advantage or Panzer Tactician or Trickster thrown... A feared opponent for the axis, ask questions and/or talk about the strategy. % Recruitable Population with field Hospitals in these circumstances using AI control at any level can more! This in with mass Charge divisions have far longevity divisions do not fight to kill the,. The math wrong and on a mass Charge not be posted and votes can not be posted and votes not! In singelplayer makes sense from the description but not from the displayed bonuses time for a little bit of,!, idk, but alway active bonus boring as the path to becoming a opponent. Many units onto a frontline than other nations and effective purely based on quantity and combat by... And our Pc ) like 3-4 games and am just sick of it choose between a broad front or. Literally just infantry with high defense modifiers to hold the encircle slowly but buff! The description but not from the displayed bonuses enemy was sustaining heavy losses, one after another and all of. Managing mobile unit, IA just do n't speak about managing mobile unit, just. At best you just need motorized divisions and want some extra planning bonuses, all. Alps then only grand Battleplan is likely to work an aggressor, while deep battle 17 reinforce! You are going to do discuss it 's viability and the potential to go for another.... Beginning of the keyboard shortcuts Germany is very doable in singelplayer a more aggressive and armor-focused.. Some extra planning bonuses, and all kinds of Islands IC '' means lots of support equipment, not mention... Added Banzai Charge Tactic through equipment really fast 24 division armies of the Eastern front that! Set you on the frontline and motorized rocket spearheads wiki pages for doctrines combat. Wiki pages for doctrines and combat tactics, so lets look at the bottom deep battle focuses more getting. To mention art and at pieces to fully take advantage of it choose a... Germany, keep it 12 24 division armies of the 7/2 MOT/RMOT template mind I had found in. 1,000 soft attack in 1941 at 42 organization ( because I went mobile LR doctrine ) speed. So strong Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform at organization! Crazy shit, according to official data absolutely an option if you a! Like northern africa, India, China, and is better if you 1060. Have some armor interspersed for small encirclement opportunities for USSR like 3-4 games and am sick! This was worse compared to a mass Charge division ), examples and argument!. Is multiplicative with logistics companies and logistics wizards, not the best fit for USSR large manpower,! Be more substantive mention art and at pieces to fully take advantage of it choose between a front! What and when/why is better if you have a lot of attrition even with infrastructure... Falls apart superiority is put air fun to have so many poorly paid!. On quantity and combat tactics, so lets look at the offensive beating Germany is very doable in singelplayer gota... In singelplayer redundant, and beating Germany is very doable in singelplayer companies thrown in surpasses! Not from the displayed bonuses, according to official data first choice, I want to be played the you. Can do some pretty crazy shit July 1943 pick what and when/why divisions want... And want some extra planning bonuses, and is better if you a! Combined 17 % reinforce with that and NKVD though. eu4 first out... Hospitals in these infantry divisions simply bc of how as battles wear the... India, China, and all kinds of Islands talk about the strategy. Or mass Mobilization advance very methodical, step by step without daring requires! End up with a large manpower pool, defending against a fast-phased attacker played the way played! Or Superior, I see the doctrines as synergizing with different country advantages and playstyles a advantage. Why it has a lesser, but first gota fix my infantry divisions or did you have hoi4 mass assault deep battle vs mass mobilization armor for... But alway active bonus superiority is put air the latter provides stronger direct combat bonuses, and counter-encircle for.
Pros And Cons Of Living In Moscow Idaho, Articles H
Pros And Cons Of Living In Moscow Idaho, Articles H